5 Mistakes That Cost You Elk & Mule Deer | Public Land Hunting Tips

5 Mistakes That Cost You Elk & Mule Deer | Public Land Hunting Tips

5 Mistakes Western Public Land Hunters Keep Making (and How to Fix Them)

Public land hunting in the West will humble you fast. It doesn’t matter how experienced you are—if you’re not paying attention to the details, small mistakes can cost you the entire season.

You’re not just fighting weather, terrain, or animals. You’re navigating pressure, unpredictability, limited time, and the mental game that comes with it. After more than three decades hunting across the West, I’ve made every one of these mistakes myself. But learning to recognize and correct them is what separates a good hunt from a frustrating one.

So let’s break down five of the biggest mission-killers I see hunters make every single season—and how to avoid them.

Mistake #1: Believing You Found a “Secret Spot”

Every hunter loves the idea of finding that “untouched” honey hole. A remote basin. A hidden wallow. A far-off ridge that looks impossible to reach.

Here’s the truth—if it’s on public land in the West, you’re not the only one who’s been there. Every hunter has OnX, GoHunt, or a similar mapping app. We’re all looking at the same ridges, meadows, and north-facing timber pockets.

If you plan your hunt assuming solitude, you’re setting yourself up for disappointment. Public land doesn’t come with assigned seats.

Don’t get frustrated when other hunters show up. Use them. Read what pressure does to the animals and adjust your plan. Elk and mule deer move fast when they feel pressure—they relocate, they adapt, and they don’t wait for you to figure it out.

Start thinking like this: other hunters are part of the chessboard. Watch what direction they move, and focus on where those bumped animals will go. Transition zones, rugged deadfall, steep sidehills—those overlooked spots often fill up with animals after opening morning.

In public land hunting, the winners aren’t the ones who find the “secret” spots. They’re the ones who adapt faster than everyone else.

Mistake #2: Staying Too Long in a Dead Zone

This one’s brutal because it’s easy to fall into. You find a basin that looks perfect. Maybe you saw rubs or fresh sign a week ago. You convince yourself, this is it.

Then the season opens, and nothing’s moving. But instead of adjusting, you sit and glass the same hillsides, day after day, hoping something changes.

It’s not a patience problem—it’s a planning problem.

You can’t force a dead spot to produce just because it “should.” The animals have moved, and you need to do the same. Every hunt plan should have multiple backup zones already marked in your e-scouting.

If the sign’s stale, the thermals aren’t right, or you’re seeing more boot tracks than fresh tracks—it’s time to go. Movement isn’t failure. It’s strategy.

Western hunting rewards adaptability. Leave ego out of it. Don’t cling to a spot because it worked last year or because it looked good on a map. Only fresh sign matters. Every day you spend in a dead zone is a day you’ll never get back.

Mistake #3: Showing Up Out of Shape

You can’t fake fitness on public land.

I’ve seen hunters who show up jacked up and ready on day one—but by day three, they’re broken. Legs are shot, back is tight, motivation gone. The mountain doesn’t care what you bench. It cares how long you can climb, how steady you can move, and how well you hold composure under fatigue.

Public land hunting isn’t hiking—it’s sustained suffering. You’re hauling gear, climbing steep elevation, and covering miles every day. Fatigue makes cowards out of even the toughest hunters.

When you’re tired, you move less, glass less, and make poor decisions. That’s when opportunities slip away.

You don’t need to be an athlete—you need to be durable. That comes from long, weighted hikes, elevation training, single-leg strength, and consistent conditioning. You’re training for the pack out as much as the hunt.

Do mock hunts. Wake up early, load your pack, hike steep ground, and shoot with an elevated heart rate. That’s the kind of work that builds the body and grit you can trust when things get hard.

Because when the mountain breaks you, no amount of gear will save you.

Mistake #4: Sloppy Access and Poor Wind Discipline

This one ruins more hunts than most people realize. Hunters spend all year e-scouting, hike miles into the backcountry, and then blow it before sunrise because they walk straight down a ridgeline with a headlamp blasting and the wind at their back.

Big game animals live and die by their senses. If they catch your scent or hear your approach, they’re gone—often for good.

Access is part of your hunt strategy, not just transportation. Move like a predator. Use shadows, avoid skylines, and understand your thermals before daylight.

Get in clean. Get out clean. If it’s noisy, go slower. If it’s quiet, move with purpose. Use a red or green light instead of a bright white headlamp. And never stomp back to camp mid-morning talking out loud or calling buddies on your phone. You’re educating every animal in the basin.

Thermals are everything. Learn how they shift through your route at different times of day. One bad wind line can erase days of effort. Plan every step of your access with scent, sound, and sight in mind.

Mistake #5: Waiting for Perfect Conditions

This one’s sneaky—it feels like smart patience, but it’s often procrastination.

“I’ll move when the wind settles.”
“I’ll go in when it cools off.”
“I’ll wait for evening light.”

Here’s the reality: perfect doesn’t exist.

The mountains are dynamic. Wind swirls. Thermals shift. Weather changes by the hour. If you wait for ideal conditions, you’ll spend half your hunt sitting still while someone else makes a move and fills their tag.

Some of my best encounters have come in less-than-ideal conditions—midday heat, swirling wind, marginal access—but I moved with purpose and played the terrain. Adaptability beats perfection every time.

If the wind is decent, the animal’s active, and the opportunity’s there—go. Later rarely means better.

You can always learn from a move that didn’t work, but you’ll never get back the chances you didn’t take.

Fixing the Mistakes

These five mistakes don’t make you a bad hunter—they make you an unprepared one. The good news is every single one of them is fixable.

Stop pretending you’re the only one out there.
Learn to hunt around pressure.
Don’t stay loyal to a dead zone.
Train your body like success depends on it—because it does.
Treat every access like a stalk.
And stop waiting for perfect conditions that don’t exist.

Hunting success in the West isn’t about luck—it’s about awareness, adaptability, and consistent effort when things get tough.

I’ve made every one of these mistakes and learned the hard way. Hopefully, you don’t have to.

Join TEAM BACKBONE

If you want to take this knowledge deeper, that’s exactly what TEAM BACKBONE is for. It’s more than a membership—it’s a crew of hunters who train harder, think sharper, and live relentless.

Inside, you’ll get:

  • Exclusive access to mindset training, backcountry strategy, and gear breakdowns.

  • 20% off sitewide on Backbone Unlimited gear.

  • A member-only t-shirt mailed every month.

  • Private community access with direct Q&A support from me.

  • Entry into monthly gear giveaways and one-on-one advice for your hunts.

If you’re ready to go beyond free tips and start living this lifestyle full-send, join TEAM BACKBONE at BackboneUnlimited.com under the Membership tab.

Until next time — Train Harder. Hunt Smarter. Never Settle.

Back to blog